I know exactly what you are saying and agree with much of it. If you are a natural pulling machine with supreme confidence maybe you can afford to look like crap. I just think that for a beginner you need to put all the odds in your favour!
Lets keep it on topic to the original post in this thread. The guy has zero results with women, I have been there and I know that (before I found out about
PUA) when I started working out and getting regular hair cuts it made a difference, not massively, but a difference none the less.
And putting PU aside, hygiene and health should be a matter of importance for anyone, its just self pride. That doesn't mean you have to join a gym and get ripped abs.