That's the point of being into Pick up is it not? To encourage those who thought they couldn't have a hot girl in a million years to go out and get it. Bollocks to accepting what generic mediocre society say to who should paired with who. If the 5/10 guy gets a 10/10 girl, surely you'd be thinking, hey he must be a f*cking dude!

As for all athletes being great looking, I've no idea how you've arrived at this. Wayne Rooney springs to mind. A lot of girls will be disguisted by guys who have rippling muscles and work out all night long. There is no norm to attraction. So being a hot guy takes on many forms, and it isn't always the square jaw.